The invention of the ship…

April 24, 2017

Share this article:

…was also the invention of the shipwreck!



Effective Leadership involves among other things a sound decision making process. As it is a process it involves looking at not only the decisions immediate impact but the longer-term effects as well. As this quote from French Philosopher, Urbanist and Cultural Theorist Paul Virilio suggests, there is casualty in every leadership decision. For context, the decisions discussed here are primarily focused on the ones with the broadest impact to the organization and the strategy. Understanding the impact the decisions have in a broader sense is the challenge every leader faces multiple times a day!


  • There are always Pros and Cons – The first thing to understand is that every decision has pros and cons. Seems obvious, yet I routinely see leaders making decisions only based on the upside of their decision and falling victim to their own confirmation biases. A common occurrence is a case study assignment I give to MBA students. Part of the assignment involves identifying the pros and cons of decisions within the case study. The number one reason these future leaders lose points is only listing the pros of the decision when it clearly states to list both the pros and cons in the syllabus. Time and again, what they perceive to be the right approach falls short by not looking at the negative, as well as the positive, consequences of key leadership decisions!
  • Managing Risk – Suffice it to say, most decisions at this level have a level of risk based on the pros and cons of that decision. Once again, we are dealing with the leader’s attitude toward risk and how the final decision is made. I suspect that if those who did invent the ship had known about shipwrecks, they would not have changed their decision. 21st Century leaders have a similar challenge in that even if they have full view of all the significant pros and cons, they would still make decisions where the cons will show, but only with minimal impact relative to the advantages (pros) of the decisions.
  • Impact of Pace – Once leaders have the pros and cons identified and have come to terms with their risk tolerance, they fact the impact of pace. Simply stated, the speed of business does not allow unbounded time to confer, deliberate and reflect on key decisions. As leaders will never have enough time to do all they want to do (hence the need for priorities), they will rarely have enough time to make the perfect decision. Although a common complaint among leaders is not having enough time, my response to them is to know their business well enough to be able to quickly put key decisions into context. Getting feedback from the leader’s team is crucial to this continuous business knowledge process such that only a small amount of additional information is needed at the time to make the best decision for the organization!


Effective Leadership decision-making is both an art and a science. It involves looking at both short term and long term impacts to the organization and involves making tough decisions even with an occasional shipwreck as part of the impact!


Is your next decision a ship, a shipwreck or a little bit of both and how do you know?


Lead Well!

Follow Us:

Our Latest Insights

By Rick Lochner • October 26, 2026
...by its resiliency in uncertainty”
How are you leveraging AI to differentiate your business?
By Rick Lochner • September 28, 2026
...so that you can do something about it now”
By Rick Lochner • August 26, 2026
...it’s the product of their interaction.” While we’ve written intermittently about systems and processes, the current VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Comple, Ambiguous) business environment compels us to spend more time on how important systems thinking is to effective leadership. We are using the title quote from the late Russell Ackoff , who was a pioneer in the field of operations research, systems thinking and management science. And to illustrate the importance of the title quote, we will use a case study we came across a year ago to drive the point home. The project was a joint venture between General Motors and Toyota named the New United Motor manufacturing, Inc. or NUMMI for short. The goal of the venture was to apply the lessons Toyota learned around lean manufacturing to a failing GM plant in Fremont, California. The results were dramatic in the increased productivity of the plant proving that transformation could occur with fundamentally the same personnel in the plant before and after the switch. While the application of lean methodologies succeeded in producing much improved results, the lessons learned were ultimately lost on GM leadership. They concluded that it was the processes alone that created the change since the personnel were basically the same. In fact, it was the interrelationships between the processes that carried the success of the venture overall. Today, that plant is owned by Tesla. So, what does that mean in a VUCA business environment? It means that leaders trying to react and flex to pieces and parts of the system that are impacted by change will struggle to solve the problem in a sustainable way. It is understanding that volatility and/or complexity, while deeply affecting one particular part of the system, ultimately has systemic impacts across other systems as well. It also means that uncertainty and/or ambiguity will make it difficult to ascertain where the solution lies without looking at the business through the lens of systems thinking. Now, just for the fun of it, let’s throw in the impact of artificial intelligence (AI). The AI impact has come at the business environment with a vengeance to the point where we are already seeing the strategic and systemic challenges encountered by early adopters. In our estimation, it once again looks like business leaders are adopting AI as a workforce replacement instead of addressing where AI fits into the current and desired systems approach to the business. Once again, the absence of being able to see the interrelationships between systems creates major blind spots and lessons not learned similar to the NUMMI and GM venture. From our 2022 book, “ Finding the Missing Piece : The Impact of Effective Communications on sustainable Success”, we define systems thinking as, “...a holistic approach focusing on how a system’s components work together, how a system operates over time as well as how it operates in the context of other larger systems.” The only way systems can provide the foundational value to the organization is through leaders who can fully appreciate and understand its benefits, especially in a VUCA business environment! How are your leadership interactions enhancing the business systems? If you’re not sure, we can help . Lead Well!